Judge Katherine Failla of the Southern District of New York ruled in favor of Kickstarter that the US patent “Methods and Apparatuses for Financing and Marketing a Creative Work” granted to ArtistShare should be invalidated.
The dispute between the 2 parties started over 4 years ago, and although ArtistShare tried to convince the judge that they were not trying to own crowd-funding, the judge ruled that the patent was overly general. She said that, the “defendants’ repetition of words like ‘particular’ and ‘specific’ in bold italics when referring to the claims in the ‘887 Patent does not make them so.”